Peter Shields Inn Ownership Change Signals New Era for Cape May Landmark

Peter Shields Inn ownership change brings Carl and Megan Messick to the historic Cape May landmark, with operations continuing uninterrupted

A major Peter Shields Inn ownership change is underway as the iconic Cape May beachfront destination prepares to welcome new leadership after 16 years under its current owners. The announcement was made through a social media statement, where the outgoing ownership team shared news of the transition with guests and supporters.

Located at 1301 Beach Avenue, Peter Shields Inn & Restaurant has earned a reputation for its fine dining, oceanfront views, and historic Georgian Revival architecture. The property has long been considered one of Cape May’s most cherished hospitality destinations.

“It is with both joy and sadness that we announce we will be passing the torch of one of Cape May’s most cherished destinations on to an enthusiastic new ownership team,” the owners stated.

Carl and Megan Messick Take Over

The Peter Shields Inn ownership change will place the inn and restaurant under the leadership of Carl and Megan Messick. Carl Messick is well known to the property, having spent more than a decade as executive chef at Peter Shields Inn before opening his own restaurant, Grana BYOB.

His return is expected to provide continuity while introducing new opportunities for growth. The outgoing owners expressed confidence that the new team will continue the inn’s tradition of outstanding hospitality and memorable dining experiences.

Operations to Continue Without Interruption

The Peter Shields Inn ownership change is expected to be seamless for guests. Both ownership teams are working closely together to ensure a smooth transition.

Management confirmed that all existing reservations, private events, and gift cards will be honoured during and after the ownership transfer. The restaurant will continue serving dinner seven days a week from 5 p.m. to 8 p.m., while the inn remains open daily.

The outgoing owners reflected on their 16-year stewardship, highlighting the restoration and enhancement of the historic property as well as the relationships built with loyal guests. Additional details about future plans are expected to be announced in the coming weeks.

As one chapter closes and another begins, Peter Shields Inn appears poised to maintain its reputation as one of Cape May’s premier dining and lodging destinations.

FAQs

1. Who are the new owners of Peter Shields Inn?

Carl and Megan Messick will take ownership of Peter Shields Inn & Restaurant.

2. Who is Carl Messick?

Carl Messick previously served as executive chef at Peter Shields Inn for more than ten years before opening Grana BYOB.

3. Will the inn and restaurant remain open during the transition?

Yes, both businesses will continue operating without interruption.

4. Will existing reservations and gift cards still be accepted?

Yes, all reservations, events, and gift cards will be honored during and after the ownership change.

5. When will more details about the transition be announced?

The ownership teams said additional information about the transition will be released in the coming weeks.